ENGAGEMENT

“Do We Still Belong There?” Interfaith Climate Organizations’ Critical Engagement at COP28

By Sarah Hautzinger, Professor of Anthropology, Colorado College

People from a variety of faith traditions gather at the Faith Pavilion of the United Nations climate summit COP28 for an interfaith walk through the venue, calling together from their respective perspectives for climate justice. Photo: Lutheran World Federation/Albin Hillert

“We have to ask ourselves: Do we still belong there?” The speaker, Regina Banks, directs California’s Lutheran Office of Public Policy, and was one of those featured at a post-COP debrief titled “The Faith Voice at COP28” convened by the group Interfaith Power and Light. She asked the question in recognition of COP29 shaping up as a repeat of COP28, hosted by an oil-producing (and authoritarian) nation with its national-petroleum CEO being named president, possibly with staggering numbers of fossil-fuel lobbyists (over 2,400 in Dubai) again in attendance.

Answers to this question vary depending on the positioning and agendas of different Faith-Based Organizations (FBOs1). The recognition of potentially diminishing returns on COPs as spaces for “hearing the moral and ethical voice” that FBOs in particular bring, however, is significant and widely shared. This account draws upon my participation at COP28 (and three previous COPs), including two high-level, closed interfaith sessions, as well as interviews with leaders of several interfaith organizations with longstanding presence at COPs.

COP28 in Dubai was the first to feature a faith-based pavilion, offering a central location where 130 FBOs convened and providing a fertile space for circulating experiences, education, and networking. In view of the substantial costs (several hundred thousand dollars) of putting up the infrastructure and programming, though, some did ask if the resources might be better spent, such as through sponsoring journalists and religious writers to focus on moral and ethical aspects. Others worried that the proliferation of pavilions in general contributed to a trade show environment, accommodating the hugely bloated number of “national overflow” delegates without clear purpose but enjoying the prestige of attending COP28. 

Preceding the pavilion by a decade, the Interfaith Liaison Committee (ILC) to the UNFCCC was established in 2013 as a “Special Group” that would “support the informal gathering of faith-based organization.” In the years since 2017, when Fiji introduced the Talanoa Dialogues at COP23 (Kirsh 2021, Hautzinger 2024), the ILC has convened a pre-COP Talanoa with over 200 FBO leaders. Valériane Bernard, ILC Co-Chair and affiliated with Brahma Kumaris, called these gatherings a “moment of care” and “emotional nourishment,” building solidarity and fortitude in preparation for the work ahead. 

Valeriane Bernard of the Brahma Kumaris community (right) hands over the outcome of a call from faith communities at COP28, stemming from a Talanoa dialogue undertaken as the conference began, to Ahmed Al Ghardaqa (left) of the COP28 presidency, at COP28. Photo: Lutheran World Federation/Albin Hillert

A prime achievement of the ILC in association with FBOs has been injecting human rights into climate-based work. Repeatedly at COP28, I heard invocations of “vulnerability” and “loss and damage” countered with assertions that the losses and threats aren’t just about property and assets but of homelands, languages and lifeways. Nor are they “accidents” to be naturalized. Recognizing that these constitute human rights violations, first and foremost, contradicts tendencies to cast them in purely economistic and market-based terms. At first, Bernard reports, there was resistance: “Human rights was exclusively [at the UN] in Geneva, and climate here, at the COPs. We were trying to bridge the two and being told, no, each stays in its place. It took years to make both entities understand that you can’t separate them; they are together.” These efforts have led to a series of special mechanisms interrelating the two and a 2022 mandate to “receive human rights complaints made against states, international organizations or private actors.”

Greenfaith is an international, grassroots, multifaith, climate justice organization. Founding director and an Episcopalian priest Fletcher Harper, told me, “My feeling is that if religious groups are going to show up at COP, they should show up well educated, with specific goals about what they’re going to do to criticize lack of progress. . .  They should not show up to socialize, they should not show up because it’s a cool place to be. They should show up with a clear, morally and religiously informed political agenda.” 

With Greenfaith’s increasingly critical orientation, their goals for COP participation have grown more focused in response. At COP28, the organization sent a smaller team than they had in previous years, due in part to other priorities. But examples of the focused, critical objectives they executed included “birddogging” representatives of several Japanese banks in attendance that are extensively financing new fossil fuel extraction in eastern Africa. “Because we know [Japanese bankers] are uncomfortable with public confrontation, and they don’t experience that on their home turf,” Greenfaith delegates called them out with the theatrical flair so well-honed by religious clergy and laypeople.  

Similarly, when members of the Ugandan government presented the East Africa crude oil pipeline as an example of sustainable development, African Greenfaith delegates were there to challenge this. 

“That kind of arena doesn’t exist in civil society inside Uganda,” Harper observed, “and it’s not safe to do that inside Uganda.” In such instances the COP becomes a point of opportunity to expose greenwashing but also abuses such as desecration of graves and, of course, pollution of air and water.  

If Greenfaith’s focus at COP is making political interventions and the ILC’s is shaping UN practices, many more nationally focused FBOs use the COPs to hold their governments accountable. Interfaith Power and Light (IPL), based primarily in the United States, focuses on “tracking what is being said and done by the US Delegation at the COP,” Reverend Susan Hendershot said. This then “can inform the work that we are doing on Federal policy at home. We look at it like this: it’s really challenging for the US to go in and make promises to the global community that it can’t make progress on here in the US.” Whether because Congress holds funding purse-strings or resists implementing necessary regulation, complying with global climate commitments requires representatives to be hearing from their constituents. IPL seeks to act as a liaison between constituents and the US Congress. 

To return to the question of benefits versus drawbacks to participating at COP, it is useful to think about the position of FBOs in relation to the UN as a whole. In a vital sense, FBOs have epitomized civil society and non-governmental organization engagement, overall, at the United Nations since its inception 75 years ago. The Church Center for the United Nations building in New York City, for example, has historically housed not only FBOs but some of the first NGOs with constant and influential UN presence. In what is widely understood as a post-Cold War ‘religious resurgence’ and a ‘postsecular’ international landscape (Haynes 2014), climate in particular has garnered increasing attention of FBOs, with a majority ecumenical Christian presence, but also marked by Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist and Jewish involvement.

Assiduous separation between the secular/governmental UN parties and religious organizations has held importance from the beginning, perhaps echoing observations, for example, about secular “chiefs” in contrast to sacred “leopard skin priests” that became ubiquitous in early political anthropology (Evans-Pritchard 1956); these may pose particularly powerful forms of checks and balances, both structuring and modeling civil-society engagement. Thinking about Faith-Based Organizations (FBOs), however, in relation to climate change in broad terms summons up paradoxes: faith orientations can compel both action (along with mutual trust, discipline and sacrifice; Sosis and Alcorta 2003) and denialism (Zahala and Szasz 2013, Taylor 2016, Bjork-James in prep.). Further, they may both center Earth-care values and practices (which may or may not translate into political action, Hautzinger in prep.) or treat these as incidental to their spiritual or theological concerns, which may be other-wordly, anthropocentric and/or nature-indifferent. My interlocutors from FBOs with presence at UN climate COPs underline their diversity in other ways: as Valériane Bernard put it, some are more “spiritual” and others “religious” in orientation, some more conservative and others more progressive. Even so, they note that at COPs the earth-centered and progressive ends of the spectra are more in evidence; the considerable effort and expense required to engage at the international level hold little attraction for more conservative and less political groups. 

Do FBOs still belong at COP? Those I interviewed, despite their quandaries and concerns about the cooptative, coercive or corruptive forces at work, at the end of the day seemed more concerned about what it would mean for FBOs not to be there, or to give up on COP and all it represents – the Paris Agreement and UNFCCC work writ large. Myra Jackson, Permanent UN Representative for the Global Commons cluster, spoke to the question directly: 

“Faith can’t go away. Faith needs to stay there. It’s one of those places, for many, where values inform action. That’s a question of faith… What people will truly act on are often two things: what they fear and what they value. When they feel what they value is at risk, that’s where fear can take over. And what brings people back to the restoration of being able to take action is when they have faith that a future that they desire can be accomplished through such action, through participation.”

Jackson extols the work FBOs have accomplished with regard to bridging climate justice and human rights, but observes there’s much left to do – especially regarding hearing “the Earth itself” in climate work and bolstering efforts like seeking legal recognition of the Rights of Nature. This might require greater attention to the relative distance between most Indigenous groups at COP and current FBOs as largely “global-religion”-based, which according to Susan Hendershot, stems in particular from wariness of working with the same Christian groups tied to colonialism and genocide in Indigenous memories.

As these final points underline, the same thoughtful divisions of labor that enable much UN work can also become impediments in seeking to rise to the all-encompassing challenges climate change presents. Just as FBOs insistently insert the moral/ethical and human rights dimensions into negotiations at COP, FBOs can also continue their work to diversify the circle of voices, perspectives and practices so critical for meaningful climate action.

References

Bjork-James, S. In prep. Reproductive Futurism in Evangelical and Secular Environmental Politics.

Evans-Pritchard, E.E., 1956. Nuer religion. Oxford: Calrenden Press.

Hautzinger, S., 2024. Continuing to Talanoa: storytelling dialogues for youth engagement in climate action and justice. Sustainable Earth Reviews, 7(1), pp.1-9.

—. In prep. Climate, in Particular: Dithering and Deflection on Climate in “Dark Green” Religious Communities.

Haynes, J., 2014. Faith-based organizations at the United Nations. In Faith-based organizations at the United Nations (pp. 1-28). New York: Palgrave Macmillan US.

Kirsch S. Talanoa dialogue at UN Climate change meetings: the extraordinary encompassment of a scale-climbing Pacific Speech Genre. Oceania. 2021;91(3):330–48.

Sosis, Richard and Alcorta, Candace. 2003. Signaling, solidarity, and the sacred: The evolution of religious behavior. Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews: Issues, News, and Reviews 12:264-74.

Taylor, Bron. 2016. The Greening of Religion Hypothesis (Part One): From Lynn White, Jr and Claims That Religions Can Promote Environmentally Destructive Attitudes and Behaviors to Assertions They Are Becoming Environmentally Friendly. Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature & Culture, 10(3). 

Zaleha, Bernard Daley, and Andrew Szasz. 2013. Keep Christianity Brown! In How the World’s Religions are Responding to Climate Change. Robin Globus Veldman, ed. Pp. 209-228. Routledge.

  1. Defined by the UN as “religious, faith-based groups, and/or faith-inspired groups which operate as registered or unregistered non-profit institutions.” ↩︎

Sarah Hautzinger is a professor of anthropology at Colorado College. A feminist political anthropologist, her work has historically focused on violence, as reflected in books Violence in the City of Women: Gender and Battering in Bahia, Brazil (2007) and Beyond Post-Traumatic Stress: Homefront Struggles with the Wars on Terror (with Jean Scandlyn; 2014). Currently, she researches local-to-global, human rights and faith-based dimensions of climate justice social movements.