ENGAGEMENT

COP City and the Caribbean Climate Masquerade

By Ryan Cecil Jobson, The University of Chicago

In November 2023, Caribbean heads-of-state, government ministers, and environmental advisors arrived in the United Arab Emirates for the COP28 Climate Change Conference of Parties at Expo City, Dubai. For representatives of small-island developing states, the familiar talk of climate debt financing, disaster relief, and environmental vulnerability from prior COP meetings took on a different tenor against the backdrop of the UAE. Before COP, the host country and world’s seventh-largest oil producer engaged in a public makeover that swapped the image of an opulent petro-state for that of a champion of sustainability and renewable energy.

Billboards lined the highway from Dubai International Airport to Expo City announcing the arrival of COP28 with pithy taglines such as “Our Greatest Investment is Planet Earth” and “From Pledge to Change.” Along the Dubai Metro route to the Expo City conference site, isolated wind turbines sponsored by the British renewable outfit Octopus Energy (a partner of the state-run Emirati outfit, Masdar) rose conspicuously from the desert.

US oil majors claimed a piece of the action too. ExxonMobil — insisting that we can have our proverbial cake and eat it too — sponsored another billboard series to preach the virtues of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) technologies. As a leading advocate of CCS and host to an outpost of the Global CCS Institute at its Masdar City campus in Abu Dhabi, the host nation modeled a future in which fossil fuels and climate mitigation can comfortably coexist.

Climate collective Clean Creatives called out this masquerade as a propaganda campaign coordinated by public relations firms and advertising agencies to “strengthen the overall reputation and standing of the UAE…among Western audiences.” Any remaining hope that the cleaning exercise indicated a genuine commitment to carbon mitigation dissolved before the summit officially began. On November 21, COP28 President and CEO of the Emirati state oil company, Adnoc, disputed the scientific consensus when he claimed there “is no science out there, or no scenario out there, that says that the phase-out of fossil fuel is what’s going to achieve 1.5C.”

Inside the credentialed space of COP28’s “Blue Zone,” Caribbean government officials struck a different chord as they underscored the disproportionate vulnerabilities faced by small-island developing states1. In plenary sessions and side events, Caribbean Community (CARICOM) heads of state and government officials decried the perils of life in “hurricane alley” and insisted time and again that “we did not cause” the crisis of anthropogenic climate change.

The “we” in this clause obscures far more than it reveals. As the mask came off the Emirates cleaning exercise, we might ask why Caribbean leaders did not direct their grievances to Al Jaber himself. Without naming the causes of climate change — multinational fossil fuel companies and the carbon consumption patterns of transnational elites—CARICOM leaders staged a masquerade in which their own structural complicity remained hidden from view. As I detail in my forthcoming monograph, The Petro-State Masquerade: Oil, Sovereignty, and Power in Trinidad and Tobago, the state form can be best understood as a masquerade in which diplomatic performances and infrastructural spectacles permit the state to lay claim to a monopoly on political practice (Jobson 2024). At COP28, this masquerade proceeded as Caribbean heads-of-state adorned themselves in the language of vulnerability at a distance from the most vulnerable populations in their own nations and territories. Instead, by refusing to condemn fossil fuel and mining companies with Caribbean investments and foreign financiers from the U.S., Europe, China, and the Gulf, Caribbean statesmen and elites played their role in the larger masquerade of COP28 to perfection.

COP City: Dubai

As with past meetings, COP28 at Expo City was divided into distinct zones: A “Green Zone” that is free and open to the general public and a “Blue Zone” limited to credentialed parties and delegates. Within the Blue Zone, another divide was palpable between the more intimate and participatory panels and events hosted at organizational pavilions and the curated plenary sessions in large exhibition halls. Further, the conference customarily opens with a two-day “high-level segment” in which heads-of-state deliver speeches and host other “party events.” The arrangement of country pavilions pushed them into isolated cabinets on the Expo City grounds that discouraged the usual proximity that characterized previous COP meetings in Egypt and Scotland.

Historically, World’s Fair-style pavilions display representative exhibits of individual state delegations and emerging technologies. In taking the unit of the nation-state for granted, World’s Fairs obscured antagonisms within nation-states between rulers and the citizen masses that toil beneath them. Peasants, fisherfolk, or Indigenous communities may be put on display as icons of national heritage or pageantry, but their independent political will is subordinated to the elite figureheads of the nation.

COP28 embraced this form through country pavilions and addresses delivered by heads-of-state from each recognized nation. But COP is not a pure spectacle. Indigenous peoples and climate activists make their presence felt even within the securitized theater of Dubai’s Blue Zone. Occasionally, these actions spilled out into the open-air plaza of Expo City as protesters demanded “No More Fossils” and defended the dignity of Indigenous livelihoods, lands, and waters. Unlike the curated backdrop of state pavilions, the open-air forums permit ordinary participants to refuse their conscription as passive icons of national heritage and unity.

Meanwhile, in areas curated for “high-level” negotiations and plenaries — ostensibly open to any Blue Zone delegate — global statesmen could assume the pulpit without the threat of disruption by unruly activists. Appointed representatives of each member state are permitted to speak in turn. Dissident voices from within their borders—working people, dispossessed peasants, and Indigenous nations—are not.

“SIDS: A Just and Equitable Energy Transition Towards a Climate-Resilient Future,” Expo City, Dubai, 5 December 2023. Photo by author.

One high-level event convened under the title “SIDS: A Just and Equitable Energy Transition Towards a Climate-Resilient Future.” Staged in the stately Al-Waha Theater, the program featured a roster of Caribbean government ministers alongside their Indian Ocean and Pacific counterparts.

Anticipating the Fourth International Conference on Small Island Developing States in Antigua and Barbuda next May, CARICOM speakers fell into line for their masquerade. Just as Caribbean masqueraders collect their costumes in the prelude to regional Carnivals, CARICOM leaders adorned themselves in the flags of the region and proclaimed themselves the authentic voices of Caribbean people to the audience in Dubai.

One might ask why representatives of small-island states located at the disaster-prone peripheries of metropolitan capital would not join the demonstrations staged by their grassroots, Indigenous counterparts. Indeed, many also hail from vulnerable coastal and inland communities. This missed connection was not incidental. Despite espousing similar rhetoric, Caribbean state officials had a different agenda than the clamors for “No More Fossils” that resounded through the tightly policed COP (Expo) City.

In high-level negotiations, Caribbean leaders engaged their Emirati hosts in talks and broker compacts. This included a Promotion and Protection of Investment Agreement between Barbados and the UAE and the approval of a US$700m Loss and Damage Fund that CARICOM included on its “wish list” delivered to COP28 President Al Jaber in August.

The urgent necessity of climate mitigation in the Caribbean cannot be overstated. But the failure to name the culprits themselves (or boycott negotiations in solidarity with front-line activists) demonstrates that the language of vulnerability is less a genuine protest than a negotiation tactic to secure financing from North Atlantic and Gulf paymasters. In the theater of “COP City,” Caribbean government ministers masquerade as grassroots activists by co-opting the language of climate justice and autonomy.

Caribbean leaders liberally indulged the language of “community empowerment” supplied by decentralized renewable microgrids as alternatives to diesel and natural gas. Indeed, few would object to a popular democratic vision of a Caribbean society founded on energy sustainability and self-management by ordinary people themselves. This would require CARICOM to confront the possibility that the visions of ordinary people may diverge from, or contradict, their own. 

The framing of “loss and damage” as a principal feature of the CARICOM wishlist, though, indicates a different objective for the schemes brokered between elite actors in Dubai. Community empowerment, by their calculus, must wait until a sufficient sum of cheques arrive. Climate justice is doled out after the fact of disaster, with the inevitability of “loss and damage” accepted as a basic condition of claims-making for Caribbean communities on the front lines of climate change.

The tragic reality is that the rising waters and tempestuous winds of climate change will take out the peripheral islands and inlets first. The parliament halls and state houses, even when they are affected by disaster events, will be protected and restored. Those truly at its most vulnerable peripheries, the workers and peasants of outlying Caribbean islands of Bequia, Carriacou, Barbuda, and Nevis, for instance, are not afforded a role on the stage at COP28. As I observe elsewhere, this masquerade recurs in the CARICOM Reparations Commission where the dispossession of Caribbean working people is mobilized as a pretext for public-private partnerships between Caribbean governments and multinational corporations. In the absence of the most vulnerable and dispossessed, the petty elites who govern them are permitted to speak in their voice while brokering compacts with oil and mining multinationals and preferential capital financing for their private sector partners. But ordinary Caribbean people may soon crash the party with a masquerade of their own.

Meet the Brownes

The CARICOM delegations to COP28 reflected what anthropologist David Hughes calls a Caribbean “climate intelligentsia” that deploys narratives of vulnerability to “disguis[e] complicity and “displaces conscience” (Hughes 2017, 122). A brief tour of the region proves as much. Guyana has forged ahead with deepwater oil development as the latest episode in its post-independence saga of ethnic patronage politics. Trinidad and Tobago seeks desperately to replicate Guyana’s success and revive its own sputtering oil and gas sector. Barbados hopes to join the fête with its own push to monetize offshore oil reserves along its maritime border with Trinidad. In none of these cases have leaders suggested that extractive revenues be managed by peasants and workers themselves. Instead, they draw inspiration from the Emirati model—in which carbon capture and storage technologies will permit them to accumulate petrodollars and supply a remedy for anthropogenic climate change.

In Antigua and Barbuda, Prime Minister Gaston Browne exploited the devastation of Hurricane Irma to displace Barbudans and declare an end to its centuries-long communal land tenure system. While insisting that the people of the Caribbean are uniquely imperiled by climate change, Caribbean leaders take their turn masquerading as “the people” at a safe distance from their own populations in Dubai.

This masquerade came into full view during the comments delivered by Antigua and Barbuda Ambassador for Climate Change, Diann Black-Layne, at the aforementioned SIDS plenary. Again, compared to the near total devastation of the smaller Barbuda, Antigua suffered minimal long-term damage as a result of Category 5 Hurricane Irma in 2017. Barbuda, however, did not warrant a single mention of its own. Instead, the devastation of Barbuda was permitted to stand in for the vulnerability of the archipelagic nation as a whole.

After sharing her “excitement” ahead of the SIDS Summit in Antigua scheduled for May 2024, Black-Layne turned her attention to her “small Caribbean nation” of origin:

We were hit by the first Category 5 hurricane. So all of my negotiators including myself, my Minister, our Prime Minister…We know what we’re talking about. We were there when the Category 5 hit our shores, our communities. And so there’s a passion, there’s an urgency that we would like to see that everybody can adopt. So, Antigua and Barbuda is like every other Small Island Developing State. We suffer with getting access to capital for renewable energy…And so the strategy for Antigua and Barbuda and we hope to show to you when you get there is that we want to harness the power of our people, our savings, and our own local financial institutions. The solar panel system that exists on my home was expensive because it cost twice as much, I pay twice as much as somebody who lived in the United States. And I don’t make the kind of salary they make. But I purchased it anyway and there’s a lot of saving you can have. And I use the financing in my own local bank — my own community bank — and install it into my own home. When the hurricane hit, the next day I had power.

Black-Layne insisted that Hurricane Irma endowed the political class of Antigua and Barbuda with an intimate knowledge of climate disaster. In fact, while Barbudans were displaced for months, prohibited from returning home, and subject to land grab schemes by the Browne administration, the Ambassador had her power restored a single day after Irma.

She did not expect the global audience at COP28 to be alert to this paradox. Black-Layne and her associates play a mas as “small” men and women at the very same moment that they collaborate to illegally terminate communal land tenure and transform Barbuda into a tourist paradise. In Dubai, their masquerade was successful. The audience was not permitted to raise the question of Barbuda.

Throughout COP28, Caribbean politicians and professionals descended on Dubai to collect their costumes in their preferred section of the Emirati climate masquerade. Safely cloistered away from the people of Barbuda, Antiguan officials played a mas(querade) as Barbudans themselves. When the theater shifts from Dubai to St. John’s for the May 2024 SIDS Summit in Antigua, their masquerade may not prove as successful.

  1.  The United Nations (UN) designation of Small-Island Developing States (SIDS) refers to a distinct group of 39 member states and 18 associate members of the UN located in the Caribbean, the Pacific, and the Atlantic, Indian Ocean and South China Sea (AIS). ↩︎

References

Hughes, David McDermott, Energy without Conscience: Oil, Climate Change, and Complicity (Durham: Duke University Press, 2017).

Jobson, Ryan Cecil. The Petro-State Masquerade: Oil, Sovereignty, and Power in Trinidad and Tobago (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2024).


Ryan Cecil Jobson is the Neubauer Family Assistant Professor of Anthropology at the University of Chicago. He is an anthropologist and social critic of the Caribbean and the Americas. His research and teaching engage issues of energy and extractivism, states and sovereignty, climate and crisis, race and capital. His first book, The Petro-State Masquerade: Oil, Sovereignty, and Power in Trinidad (The University of Chicago Press, 2024), is a historical ethnography of fossil fuel industries and postcolonial state building.