ENGAGEMENT

The ‘Spectacle’ of Youth Participation at COP 28 

By Mark Ortiz, the Pennsylvania State University

An image of the exterior of the Youth Hub in the COP 28 Green Zone, Dubai, UAE. Photo taken by Author.

Introduction: Youth Representation as Political Aspiration & ‘Content’ 

As I wandered around the massive Expo City in Dubai during my first day at COP 28, I arrived at a building in the ‘Green Zone’ – the civil society space of the COP – called the “Youth Hub.” The interior design of the Youth Hub featured captivating multimedia videos highlighting examples of youth-driven climate solutions, extolments of the role of youth in sustainable development written on the walls, and efforts to situate investment in youth as a prominent feature of Emirati national identity and nation-building efforts. 

A photo of one of the interior rooms in the Youth Hub at COP 28 set aside for content creators. Photo taken by author.

The Youth Hub also featured a room set aside for “content creators,” people who are involved in producing digital or social media content often as a compensated or professional service (see previous image). The Hub, by design, was simultaneously a site of intergenerational interchange and a content production factory. 

Far from a spatial coincidence, I suggest that ‘content creation’ may be exactly what the adults in the room – from state and corporate leaders, to U.N. officials –  envision as the role of youth participation in the multilateral process. The entanglement of youth engagement as a political-representational aspiration and marketable ‘content’ captures a key tension in climate and sustainable development politics within a capitalist frame today. 

Youth Engagement at COP 28 

Young people have had a formal presence in the U.N. climate negotiations for nearly a decade and a half – although informally this presence stretches back even farther. Compared to previous COPs I have attended (COPs 21-23) and followed virtually (COPs 24-27), both the scale and diversity of youth engagement at COP 28 were greater. The category of youth in the context of the U.N. climate processes includes anyone below 35 years of age. Historically, this has meant a lot of twenty-somethings and young adults find themselves attending the COP with fewer children or teenagers under 18 present. COP 28 was different in this respect, featuring the participation of a wider variety of young people from frontline communities and children under 18 along with an overall greater attention to childrens’ rights, youth issues, and their intersections in official programming.

However, as youth ‘representation’ becomes more of a drumbeat of official climate policy programming, the nature of youth engagement is taking on a glossier image which raises doubts about its substance. Profiles of youth climate “champions” abound attached to stories of overcoming adversity. Charismatic children and young people are invited to stage to share their challenges and their hopes, to reassure largely adult audiences that hope is still in order. Social media follower count now goes a long way to acquiring invitations to these high-level, youth-focused speaking events. There is an ambivalent space of opportunity now open, with the opportunities for individual career-making and influence-building –  a chance to be invited to the next COP or other forum –  potentially sitting in tension with the larger objectives of climate movements. 

The spatial markers of this youth emphasis were widely present across the sprawling Expo City at COP 28. On one end, albeit distant from the actual negotiating halls, were situated spaces of youth engagement, from inter-university pavilions to the Climate Live Pavilion featuring a combination of musical acts, conversations led by youth advocates, and other youth-focused events. Also relevant were the Children and Youth Pavilion, which featured an entire slate of youth-focused programming, and the Entertainment+Culture Pavilion, which skewed young. Phrases that emerged across conversations in these civil society and youth-centered spaces compose an interesting tapestry: “We are the boardroom of the future!” one young speaker noted on a slide, and words like “pioneering” would frequently appear, suggesting an entanglement of notions of youth with innovation, entrepreneurialism, and inventiveness (also noteworthy are the colonial and capitalist overtones of these phrases). I met young people below the age of 10 who had already given TED talks on their climate work. 

The nature of youth participation at COP 28, I argue, was inseparable from these associations and the deluge of splashy announcements that would come out of COP 28. The host country UAE would widely publicize its Youth Climate Delegate Program, described in the COP 28 official webpage as “the largest initiative to expand youth participation in the international climate negotiation process to date.” Emailing one longtime youth advocate and COP attendee shortly after the COP 28, they told me that in contrast to this official narrative that “the UAE should thank the marketing team” for giving the conference a youth-inclusive appearance without the substance to match. 

Youth Internet Celebrity and the Politics of “Spectacle”

In an evolving ecology of policymaking, it’s not just the physical COP that is important. There is a growing centrality to the digital re-presentations and marketing of environmental events. Environmental politics scholar Carl Death (2012) has described the annual COP meeting as a form of “summit theatre,” and elements of performance, drama, and narrative have received no shortage of attention in recent scholarship on climate politics (see Smith and Howe, 2015). However, the evolution of just what ‘role(s)’ children and youth play in this theatrical production that is increasingly (re)staged across digital media platforms deserves closer scrutiny. For many scholars and journalists, young people invoke a sort of moral authority as representatives linking the earth’s present and future and as the closest living approximation of future generations. This position is a common refrain in the rhetoric of youth climate activists at COPs, from the 2009 COP in Copenhagen where youth activists wore shirts reading “How Old Will You Be in 2050?” to the COP 28 in 2023, where children advocates, supported by UNICEF, framed their work as on behalf of their own futures and future generations. 

As Sheldon’s (2016) scholarship describes, the representational association of children with the apocalypse in environmental and climate discourses may function to depoliticize actual children and young peoples’ expressions of climate and environmental justice. In the space of the COP, this manifests as an apocalyptic loop that can be observed across the years of climate politics. If you trace the history of youth speeches in the U.N. climate process starting with Severn Cullis-Suzuki’s 1992 speech at the Rio Earth Summit to the speeches young people delivered at COP 28, you can observe the same basic sequence of events play out year after year. The child activist speaks movingly of their lived experience of climate change and urgent aspirations for justice, adults applaud, perhaps a standing ovation and a few photo opportunities, then the uproar subsides, and business proceeds as usual. 

Since it demands little by way of political transformation, this proximity to apocalypse in representations of climate change carries a level of cultural appeal and marketability, both profoundly shaped by the sordid fusion of racialized imaginaries of apocalypse – who makes it and who does not – and internet celebrity culture. It’s a complex that youth activists themselves have critiqued. For instance, in a speech, youth climate activist Jamie Margolin described the dynamic of “The Child Stars at The End of the World” noting how corporations and governments were investing in young people, and their symbolic power, in efforts to “deny their own responsibility,” to “package sustainability as something inspiring with some pretty young faces without actually changing the systems worsening the climate crisis.” For Margolin, the ‘hope’ that corporations and governments manufacture sustainability is more of a marketing strategy than substantial commitment, and the faces of children and youth enrolled in this complex serve to extend and guarantee the viability of this order.

The foundational work of geographer Cindi Katz (2008) helps to illuminate and extend the dimensions of Margolin’s critique. Katz’s work has paved the way for deconstructing the symbolic set of associations that structure cultural understandings of childhood and youth while demonstrating how children and young people navigate the symbolic circulations that surround them in everyday life.

For Katz (2008: 5), childhood tends to function as “spectacle – a site of accumulation and commodification – in whose name much is done.” But part of the production of spectacle is the making of ‘waste.’ ‘Waste’ refers to the present/futures that are disinvested from, lifetimes shortened, presents diminished to make room for the material demands of spectacle, and the panics that emerge from doomed attempts to secure ‘innocent’ childhoods that do not exist. Waste, for Katz, is a necessary geographic underside of the production of childhood as spectacle, although the childhoods that are secured by ‘spectacle’ are often geographically or relationally distant from those childhoods that are converted to ‘waste.’ 

In the world of climate politics, this manifests as certain children and young people being elevated to the status of cultural icons with reems of ‘content’ associated with their likeness, while other present/futures and childhoods continue to be unwritten, unrepresented, and unmade. The political project of securing certain visions of childhood, continuity, youth, and planetary futurity often serves to further circumscribe the present and the possible for other young people. While youth activists in the U.S. may clamor for a Green New Deal, do we pause to ask how this energy scale-up may shape the life-worlds of children who are and will likely continue to be affected by the extraction of  the materials needed to ensure the continuity of ‘spectacle’ via the proposed, resource-intensive greening? 

Moving Beyond Spectacle and Towards Intergenerational Justice

A piece of artwork featured in the Entertainment+Culture Pavilion at COP 28 depicting adult politicians arguing amidst intensifying climate impacts. Photo taken by author.

During my time at COP 28, I found it more difficult than ever to look with sober eyes. The continued endorsement of business as usual at the negotiation outcomes made it difficult to feel any sense that intergenerational justice is on the horizon. During one workshop led by youth activists, we were asked to portray our experiences of COP 28 visually. I drew a picture that included the phrase “COP 60” along with images of flames, coal power plants, and other armatures of the fossil fuel economy as I tried to visualize the future that would emerge from this conference. I found it difficult to envision anything much different than more of the same, not because there was any lack of ‘inspiration’ on the part of everyone I met but because the inspiration available felt so overdetermined by the structural forces of spectacle. 

The intergenerational justice that young people have been demanding for over thirty years in the international climate process requires moving beyond the politics of spectacular youth activism. 

I am not suggesting that youth activists engaged in forms of what we might consider spectacular activism are in the wrong, but that the unique collision of corporate and state interests with social media ecologies, alongside the changing nature of ‘influence’ in a digital age, creates a set of material conditions that frame digital organizing work broadly. The  dangers of this setup are uniquely evident in the celebrity culture that now characterizes much youth climate advocacy. This attention economy – again, not owing to the young people who navigate it in ambivalent ways – may obscure pathways to deeper forms of climate justice and structurally quiet the voices, examples, and alternatives that may actually guide us there. 

To think beyond spectacle for Katz (2008: 15) opens up the possibility to “define a new political terrain.” So what might it mean to think or move beyond ‘spectacular’ youth climate activism when the acceleration of spectacle-making seems so inherent to the digital mobilizations of today (e.g. social media), which center conditions of virality and visibility in movement-making? One example I look to is the work of the youth network Fridays 4 Future which, through its MAPA constituency, has worked to center the present impacts of climate change on communities most affected as the starting point for intersectional thinking. For advocates involved in Fridays for Future MAPA, many from the Global South, there is a profound recognition of the write-offs that emerge from a politics grounded in spectacular youth activism, that the future-talk emanating from particular geographies tends to subsume the present of youth from communities and countries most impacted by climate change in the global narrative. FFF MAPA utilizes digital organizing to move attention flows differently, but even with this critical shift of focus, the basic structure of the internet attention economy and its innumerable absences remains largely intact. 

What I think is necessary is to tap into place-based and relational (re)imaginations and reconstitutions of what intergenerational politics and justice may look like. Many of these more radical reconstructions have been around all along, but have been marginalized or passed over and may require a partial or total divestment in focus from the popular emphasis on virality, visibility, and the spectacle or the event to flourish. Anthropologist Arturo Escobar (2001) once argued that “culture sites in places” as a response to narratives of globalization that erased the particularities of place. I think we are in a similar moment in relation to a global narrative of youth climate activism that runs the risk of elevating particular forms of advocacy at the expense of others. Yet, resistance, genuine alternatives, and possibilities for intergenerational justice also sit in places, and I hear this whenever I interview advocates who are deeply engaged in local work – in situating their intergenerational justice work in place. Having interviewed and worked with youth climate advocates on the frontlines of climate impacts in the Middle East and North Africa, the Pacific, the U.S. South, and many other contexts, the types of alternatives I hear are grounded in rich cultural traditions, a plurality of ways of conceptualizing intergenerational responsibilities, and formed from deep, intergenerational commitment to making life in place, repairing places that have experienced harm, and defending places at risk. Stitched together, these stories form a cartography of possibilities for thinking about place-based expressions of intergenerational justice. It is these alternatives, in their depth and richness, that social media ‘influence’ tends to crowd out (see Chen and LeClercq, 2022) when it is precisely these worlds and efforts to preserve them that constitute the real terrains of climate and environmental justice.

References

Death, C. (2012). “Summit Theatre: exemplary governmentality and environmental diplomacy in Johannesburg and Copenhagen,” Environmental Politics, 20(1). 

Escobar, A. (2001). Culture sits in places: reflection on globalism and subaltern strategies of localization. Political Geography, 20(2): 139-174. 

Katz, C. (2008). “Childhood as spectacle: relays of anxiety and the reconfiguration of the child.” Cultural Geographies, 15: 5-17.

Chen, A.X., and Leclercq, A. (2022, June 29). Social media influencers get media attention on climate change – Grassroots activists don’t. Teen Vogue, https://www.teenvogue.com/story/social-media-influencers-climate-change 

Sheldon, R. (2016). The Child to Come: Life After the Human Catastrophe. Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press. 


Smith, P. and Howe, N. (2015). Climate Change as Social Drama. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Mark Ortiz is an Assistant Professor of Geography at Penn State University. His research is situated at the intersections of youth political geographies, storytelling methods, climate justice, and social movement studies, with a particular interest in global youth climate activism.