ENGAGEMENT

On Permeable Waters and Landscapes: A Special Commentary

By Sayd Randle, College of Integrative Studies, Singapore Management University.

Walking along a covered aqueduct’s path through the desert, water can seem remarkably contained, cleanly separated from the surrounding terrain. You never see it, but the occasional sound of liquid sloshing within the infrastructure announces the substance moving through a landscape that it never touches. I had ample opportunity to ponder this sense of tidy segregation during a week spent following the path of the Los Angeles Aqueduct across the Mojave Desert, hiking with a documentary filmmaker named Sam. For her, the pipeline presented a visual challenge, its sun-bleached concrete surface obscuring the vital resource she was seeking to dramatize through her eventual movie. Ambling alongside the aqueduct, Sam and I passed hours discussing the difficulties inherent to crafting a film centered on such a hulking conduit and its contents – not least, the infrastructure’s apparent disassociation from the land through which it snakes. 

This sense of separation between water and environment, so seemingly self-evident during those days in the Mojave, feels fragile, probably even fictional, when considered in the context of this richly textured collection of essays. Across the authors’ accounts of the sediment-bearing rivers of Colombia’s La Mojana delta, the PFAS-tainted groundwater of Michigan, USA, and the lithium-rich salt ponds of Argentina’s Puna region, the assembled works demonstrate the value of approaching waterscapes through the lens of permeability, porosity, and mixture.

Across the authors’ accounts of the sediment-bearing rivers of Colombia’s La Mojana delta, the PFAS-tainted groundwater of Michigan, USA, and the lithium-rich salt ponds of Argentina’s Puna region, the assembled works demonstrate the value of approaching waterscapes through the lens of permeability, porosity, and mixture.

As Alejandro Camargo observes, “water is rarely only water,” the vital liquid itself serving as a medium of conveyance for a wide range of soils, debris, minerals, chemical compounds, and other substances. But the pieces also illustrate a key corollary register of entanglement to consider, showing how land itself conveys water, often via subterranean formations that humans struggle to measure and otherwise visualize. Foregrounding such dynamics of mixture and movement, the pieces signal the urgency of attending ethnographically to the materiality of water’s embeddedness in a broader environment, as well as the technopolitics of knowledge regarding those entanglements. 

The pieces signal the urgency of attending ethnographically to the materiality of water’s embeddedness in a broader environment, as well as the technopolitics of knowledge regarding those entanglements. 

Water’s role as a medium for other material orients all the assembled essays. As the authors show, what water carries with it shapes the conditions of possibility for communities to live with and make worlds alongside the substance. The stakes of such mixtures are particularly stark in Melisa Escosteguy and Maria Labourt’s account of lithium mining in Puna, where mining companies pump brine rich with the mineral from beneath desert salt flats, leaving the water to evaporate out of the solution in expansive networks of terrestrial salt ponds. Understood as life-giving in so many settings, here the water is seen by its extractors as merely a medium and eventual byproduct: the lithium carbonate and its lucrative role in energy storage motivates and organizes the project. In contrast, the water-with-chemicals examined by Colleen Linn surfaces in Michigan well water as an under-the-radar threat to human health. And the aguas monas of the Colombian rivers documented by Camargo are colored by sediment, an amalgam that supports the flourishing of fish and downstream agricultural landscapes. While valued by the people of La Mojana for these functions, the murky water demands substantial human labor to be made drinkable, highly gendered work in this context. As the authors amply demonstrate, water’s status as a medium shapes extractive, technoscientific, labor, and policy arrangements in these settings, in addition to underpinning lifeways and health outcomes. As in work centered on water’s role as a breeding ground for insects carrying diseases like dengue (Acevedo-Guerrero, 2022; Bayona-Valderrama et al., 2021; Kelly & Lezaun, 2014), this collection foregrounds the liquid’s status as a medium – rather than simply a resource or a volume – as a powerfully productive aspect of the substance.

Permeability and porosity thus emerge as essential characteristics of water. While so-called pure water is prized in many contexts, the substance’s capacity to absorb and transmit other materials defines its role in many contexts. But as the essays demonstrate, this absorptive capacity is forever entangled with that of land. Building on the work of Andrea Ballestero (2018) and Ángela Castillo Ardila (2021), Escosteguy and Labourt’s lyrical invocation of the “invisible spongy underground formations where water constantly trespasses versatile borders” beautifully captures the fluid, relational nature of water-in-the-ground (see also Powis, 2021). Linn, meanwhile, dwells on the complex movements of water and PFAS through the soil, signaling the sort of contaminating dangers commonly associated with the land’s porosity in industrialized settings. The land keeps the score, bearing marks from aggressive manufacturing, lightly regulated disposal, and extractive practices alike – as do the waters embedded within it.

Anthropologists of toxics have mobilized the register of porosity to think through the “starkly differential distribution of entanglement” across landscapes and between communities (Roberts, 2017: 596; see also Agard-Jones 2016). Such work tends to foreground anxieties over the permeability of human bodies, especifically their tendency to incorporate chemicals from the environments through which they move (Graeter, 2020; Pathak, 2020). The present collection signals the possibilities of fine-grained investigations of the porosity of land and water – particularly how both can emerge as objects of concern, governance, and, occasionally, cultivation (e.g. Randle, 2022). When, where, and why does the permeable nature of the ground beneath our feet enter the realm of active management or contestation? Linn’s account of the piecemeal emergence of PFAS measurement and mitigation both illustrates the patchy, fragmented form that such projects can take, and raises compelling questions about the relationship between the material forms of contamination and the attendant regulatory responses.

The invisibility and opacity intrinsic to many genres of land-water mixture and entanglement present challenges for efforts to manage and regulate them. Waters themselves can shield many things from view, including, as Camarago considers, both fish sought for food and human corpses that some seek to hide. Sediment, as he notes, both enables life and plays a key role in its annihilation in La Mojana, facilitating the quiet disappearance of murdered bodies. Water’s unseen underground flow paths present a different sort of danger in Puna. In the absence of direct observation or extensive historical data, mining companies produce hydrogeological models of the subterranean environment and scale their brine extraction accordingly. Local Indigenous communities, despite their richly textured knowledge of the region’s ecology, are effectively excluded from substantive discussion and debate over such pumping due to their lack of facility with this register of producing hydrological knowledge. The hidden character of the water is thus mobilized to delimit the disputes over its use, facilitating processes of extraction and dispossession in the process. As such examples attest, ignorance, inaccessibility, and uncertainty – perhaps as much as knowledge – play powerful roles the production of these arrangements.

Permeability and porosity thus emerge as essential characteristics of water.

Centered on rivers, domestic water purification practices, groundwaters, wells, and salt ponds, the collected essays are not oriented towards the concrete and copper of the water grid. How might such networked infrastructures, the subject of so much ethnographic attention in recent years, fit into an anthropology of water attuned to the forms of mixture and material entanglement documented here? As my days with the aqueduct in the desert attest, such sprawling assemblages of pipes can easily be experienced and interpreted as tidily separate from the surrounding environment. One can, of course, track the imbrications between the materiality of the water within such networks and the ways in which it “is drawn into and exceeds political formations” (Anand, 2011: 544). Combining such an approach with careful attention to processes like the contamination, evaporation, or leakage of waters within such networks might offer valuable traction in this direction, revealing new forms of hydraulic mixing both within and beyond water grids. Many such ecologies of entanglement, as this collection shows, are in the process of rapid transformation, and thus provide revealing sites through which to track the emergence of novel modes of living with water – arrangements with far-reaching social, political, and environmental stakes.

References

Acevedo-Guerrero, T. (2022). Water with larvae: Hydrological fertility, inequality, and mosquito urbanism. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space, 25148486221099801. https://doi.org/10.1177/25148486221099801

Agard-Jones, V. (2016) “Episode 35.” Cultures of Energy podcast, September 29. http:// culturesofenergy.com/ep-35-vanessa-agard-jones.

Anand, N. (2011). Pressure: The politechnics of water supply in Mumbai. Cultural Anthropology, 26(4), 542–564. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1548-1360.2011.01111.x

Ballestero, A. (2018). The Underground as Infrastructure? [Bookitem]. In Infrastructure, 

Environment, and Life in the Anthropocene (p. 17). Duke University Press. 

https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv121024s.5

Bayona-Valderrama, A., Acevedo-Guerrero, T., & Artur, C. (2021). Cities with Mosquitoes: A Political Ecology of Aedes Aegypti’s Habitats. 14(1).

Castillo Ardila, Á. (2021). Antropologías de la extracción y lo subterráneo en Colombia . In A. 

Camargo (Ed.), Antropología y Naturaleza (pp. 15–54). Asociación Colombiana de 

Antropología.

Graeter, S. (2020). Infrastructural Incorporations: Toxic Storage, Corporate Indemnity, and Ethical Deferral in Peru’s Neoextractive Era. American Anthropologist, 122(1), 21–36. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13367

Kelly, A. H., & Lezaun, J. (2014). Urban mosquitoes, situational publics, and the pursuit of interspecies separation in Dar es Salaam. American Ethnologist, 41(2), 368–383. https://doi.org/10.1111/amet.12081

Pathak, G. (2020). Permeable persons and plastic packaging in India: From biomoral substance exchange to chemotoxic transmission. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 26(4), 751–765. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9655.13365

Powis, A. (2021). The Relational Materiality of Groundwater. GeoHumanities, 7(1), 89–112. https://doi.org/10.1080/2373566X.2021.1925574

Randle, S. (2022). Ecosystem Duties, Green Infrastructure, and Environmental Injustice in Los Angeles. American Anthropologist, 124(1), 77–89. https://doi.org/10.1111/aman.13650

Roberts, E. F. S. (2017). What Gets Inside: Violent Entanglements and Toxic Boundaries in Mexico City. Cultural Anthropology, 32(4), Article 4. https://doi.org/10.14506/ca32.4.07


Sayd Randle is an ethnographer and political ecologist exploring the spatial and cultural politics of urban climate adaptation, with a geographic focus on the arid US West. Her research examines how attempts to make critical infrastructural systems more “climate resilient” transform material flows and urban lives, rearranging labor and power across the extended metropolitan landscape in the process. Her multi-scalar research highlights both the intimate and systemic effects of these initiatives, with an emphasis on their environmental justice impacts.


Activism (13) Agriculture (19) Climate Change (28) Conservation (33) Environment (29) Environmental Justice (13) India (12) Indigenous People (14) Infrastructure (27) Multi-Species Anthropology (30) Settler Colonialism (15) Socio-Environmental Justice (25) Toxicity (17) United States (35) Water (21)